Striking a Balance: The U-Shaped Relationship Between Exercise and Heart Health

FEATURE: Exercise is often hailed as a powerful and cost-effective way to prevent or manage cardiovascular disease. However, recent insights from experts suggest that when it comes to heart health, more exercise isn’t always better. Dr. Ravinder Singh Rao, an interventional cardiologist, explained in a conversation with Raj Shamani that exercise and heart health follow a U-shaped curve. This means that while moderate exercise significantly reduces cardiovascular risks, excessive or intense physical activity may actually increase the risk for some individuals.

“We have to do everything in moderation, as extreme physical activity is also associated with heart attack risk,” emphasized Dr. Rao. His comments reflect the growing body of research pointing to the *extreme exercise hypothesis*, which defines the dose-response relationship between exercise and cardiovascular health outcomes.

The U-Shaped Curve of Exercise and Heart Health

The U-shaped curve, as described by Dr. Haresh G. Mehta, director of interventional cardiology at S.L. Raheja Hospital, indicates that while low to moderate physical activity drastically lowers the risk of cardiovascular disease, very high levels of exercise can increase that risk. “The curve suggests that moderate amounts of physical activity are ideal for lowering the risk of cardiovascular disease and mortality, but pushing the body too hard, especially over long periods, can have the opposite effect,” explained Dr. Mehta.

Many studies support the idea that being active and maintaining good cardiorespiratory fitness can lower the chances of coronary heart disease. Moreover, exercise is often seen as a means to slow down the aging process, which has led to a surge in people taking up endurance sports, high-intensity interval training, and other forms of vigorous exercise. However, according to Dr. Ranjan Modi, senior consultant and head of interventional cardiology at Sarvodaya Hospital in Faridabad, “more” doesn’t always mean “better.”

“Many people around the world are now engaging in endurance training and competitive long-distance events, but we need to be cautious. Intense physical exercise, particularly in those who are not fit, can increase the risk of sudden cardiac death and acute myocardial infarction in those already at high risk,” said Dr. Modi.

The Paradox of Extreme Exercise

While moderate exercise is known to improve heart health, long-term high-intensity exercise can cause what’s known as cardiac maladaptation in certain individuals. Dr. Mehta explained that prolonged, intense exercise can lead to structural changes in the heart, including left ventricular hypertrophy, increased coronary artery calcification, and myocardial fibrosis. These changes increase the risk of conditions like atrial fibrillation (AF) and other rhythm disturbances.

“High-intensity, high-volume exercise over extended periods can induce cardiac stress, releasing biomarkers, causing myocardial scarring, and leading to rhythm disturbances,” noted Dr. Modi. He pointed to recent research showing that such changes can occur rapidly, highlighting the importance of moderation.

The key takeaway? Aerobic exercise remains one of the best ways to promote heart health, but it needs to be done in appropriate doses. Moderate aerobic activity for at least 150 minutes per week, or more intense exercise for 75 minutes weekly, can lower the risk of premature death and heart disease significantly. However, prolonged periods of intense exercise may make the heart more susceptible to early death and cardiovascular issues, Dr. Modi cautioned.

Finding the Right Balance

The link between exercise intensity and rhythm disturbances, such as atrial fibrillation, also follows a U-shaped curve. Those who are either sedentary or engage in excessive vigorous exercise are most at risk. Dr. Modi advised individuals to aim for moderate efforts and to include rest days in their routine. “Instead of going all out every day, it might be better to aim for balanced, sustainable activity and take breaks from strenuous exercise at least once a week,” he suggested.

In conclusion, while exercise is undeniably essential for heart health, more is not always better. The key lies in finding a balance, incorporating regular moderate activity while avoiding the risks that come with extreme, prolonged exercise. By doing so, individuals can enjoy the long-term benefits of physical activity without putting their hearts at risk.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Leave a Comment